Benjamin Moore vs. Kelly Moore Paints: What’s Better?

One of the hardest parts of house painting is choosing the paint, and even harder – the right brand. With tons of options promising durability, finish, and value, making the right choice can feel overwhelming.

When choosing a paint brand, many people find themselves debating between the two “Moores” — Kelly-Moore and Benjamin Moore — unsure which option is the better fit for their needs.

First of all, Kelly-Moore Paints and Benjamin Moore are not the same company.

They are unrelated, separate, and independent paint manufacturers. Benjamin Moore is a long-established premium brand, while Kelly-Moore was a regional U.S. paint company that operated mainly on the West Coast.

Much like any other business, both Kelly Moore and Benjamin Moore have a story, a history, a reputation, and their special qualities.

Below, you can compare and contrast these two brands while considering which one is best for your needs.

Benjamin Moore Paints

Having a long-running history is perhaps the best credit to Benjamin Moore’s name. Benjamin Moore Paint has been around since the year 1883.

Such a long lifespan also means they have a lot of experience in the industry.

For some homeowners, this can be seen as a perk, though other homeowners might feel wary because they worry that this means they will just operate like a big business with little regard for the customer.

Individuals who have painted their own homes usually run into the problem of needing more paint in the future to repair scratches and other marks caused by daily life. So, how easy it is to access the needed paint is important to consider.

Benjamin Moore paint can be found in various locations throughout the country. If you want to purchase more paint in the same color from the same brand, you can count on Benjamin Moore paints to be there.

Kelly Moore Paints

Founded in 1946 by William Kelly and William Moore, Kelly-Moore Paints began as a small paint store in San Carlos, California, with a clear focus on serving painters with reliable products and expert support.

Over the decades, the company expanded steadily and today operates more than 150 stores across the United States.

Kelly-Moore offers a broad range of interior and exterior paints, primers, and specialty coatings, with a strong emphasis on quality, competitive pricing, and sustainability.

Known for its advanced color-matching technology and knowledgeable customer service, the brand has long built its reputation by understanding the real-world needs of both professional painters and homeowners.

Note: Kelly-Moore, as a standalone retail chain, no longer exists. The company officially ceased all operations and closed its retail stores on January 12, 2024. This means Kelly-Moore Paints is out of business.

While the brand name may appear on new products or at select international outlets due to the intellectual property sale, the original store network and US manufacturing operations remain permanently closed. 

---

Benjamin Moore vs. Kelly Moore

When the choice comes down to Kelly-Moore vs. Benjamin Moore, the decision is less about the shared name and more about performance philosophy.

One grew as a contractor-first, value-driven brand; the other evolved into a premium benchmark trusted by designers and professionals alike.

Below is a clear, technically grounded comparison across the factors that actually matter—so you can decide with confidence, not confusion.

1. Product Range

Benjamin Moore offers a technically expansive product range, covering ultra-premium interior paints, high-performance exterior coatings, primers, and specialty solutions like moisture-resistant and self-priming formulations.

Lines such as Aura® and Regal® use proprietary Color Lock® technology for superior pigment binding.

Kelly-Moore’s range is more streamlined, focusing on practical interior and exterior paints, primers, and specialty coatings designed for efficiency and repeatability.

While narrower, its lineup is contractor-friendly and easier to navigate.

Benjamin Moore clearly leads in specialization, while Kelly-Moore emphasizes functional breadth without overcomplication—an approach many professionals appreciate for day-to-day projects.

2. Color Options

Benjamin Moore is widely recognized for its expansive and curated color palette, featuring over 3,500 colors developed using advanced tinting systems that ensure consistency across finishes. This depth explains its dominance in interior designer choices.

Kelly-Moore offers fewer shades but compensates with accurate, dependable color-matching technology suitable for most residential needs.

Ratings and feedback indicate both brands deliver excellent color accuracy, but Benjamin Moore stands out for nuanced undertones and complex neutrals.

If color psychology and precision matter deeply, Benjamin Moore has the edge; if reliability and simplicity are priorities, Kelly-Moore performs confidently.

3. Paint Quality

From a technical standpoint, Benjamin Moore consistently ranks higher in paint quality due to higher solids content, finer pigment dispersion, and advanced resin systems.

These factors contribute to smoother application, better leveling, and fewer coats. Kelly-Moore paints are well-formulated for durability and ease of use, particularly in contractor-driven environments.

Feedback from professionals often notes that Benjamin Moore excels on demanding surfaces and premium interiors, while Kelly-Moore delivers dependable, workhorse performance.

Both meet professional standards, but Benjamin Moore’s premium chemistry gives it an advantage in refinement and finish uniformity.

4. Finish Types

Both brands offer standard finishes—flat, matte, eggshell, satin, semi-gloss, and gloss—but Benjamin Moore’s finishes are engineered for enhanced washability and burnish resistance, especially in higher sheens. This makes them ideal for high-traffic interiors.

Kelly-Moore’s finishes are consistent and practical, performing well in residential and light commercial settings.

Interior designer choices often lean toward Benjamin Moore for its sheen, clarity, and tactile smoothness. Kelly-Moore remains a solid option where performance expectations are high, but budget sensitivity still matters.

5. Durability

Durability is where formulation science truly shows.

Benjamin Moore’s premium lines demonstrate superior resistance to fading, scuffing, and moisture intrusion, supported by acrylic resin technologies designed for long-term color retention.

Kelly-Moore paints also offer good durability, especially in interior applications and moderate climates. Contractor feedback frequently highlights Benjamin Moore’s edge in exterior longevity and high-wear zones.

For projects where repainting cycles must be extended, Benjamin Moore tends to outperform, though Kelly-Moore remains reliable for standard residential use.

6. Customer Reviews

Across platforms, Benjamin Moore earns consistently high ratings for finish quality, color depth, and longevity.

Customer feedback often cites fewer coats and better coverage as key advantages.

Kelly-Moore receives praise for value, service, and ease of application, particularly from contractors and homeowners managing large projects.

While Benjamin Moore is often described as “premium,” Kelly-Moore is seen as “practical and trustworthy.” Both brands maintain strong reputations, but they appeal to slightly different expectations.

7. Price Comparison

In terms of cost, Benjamin Moore generally sits at a higher price point, reflecting its advanced formulations and premium positioning.

Kelly-Moore is typically more competitively priced, making it attractive for budget-conscious projects without significant compromise on quality.

Pricing varies by product line and region, but the difference is usually justified by performance expectations rather than branding alone.

Both brands offer multiple tiers, allowing flexibility depending on scope and finish requirements.

8. Eco-Friendliness

Both companies address sustainability through low-VOC and zero-VOC formulations.

Benjamin Moore’s eco-focused lines are independently certified and designed for sensitive environments, making them popular in healthcare and residential interiors.

Kelly-Moore also emphasizes sustainability, offering environmentally responsible products suitable for occupied spaces.

While both perform well here, Benjamin Moore’s dedicated green product lines give it a slight technical advantage for strict environmental standards.

9. Availability of Products

Benjamin Moore benefits from a wide network of independent retail locations and strong online purchasing support, making it accessible nationwide.

Kelly-Moore has fewer retail locations but still maintains solid regional coverage and convenient online ordering.

Availability rarely becomes a limiting factor for either brand, though Benjamin Moore’s broader distribution offers more flexibility for large or multi-location projects.

10. Contractor Preferences

Professional recommendations often favor Benjamin Moore for premium residential and design-led projects due to its consistency and technical reliability.

Kelly-Moore remains popular among contractors who value efficiency, competitive pricing, and dependable results.

Contractor preferences ultimately depend on project type, client expectations, and budget—but both brands are respected within the trade.

Benjamin Moore or Kelly Moore Quick Comparison Table

Factor	Kelly-Moore	Benjamin Moore
Product Range	Focused, contractor-friendly	Broad, highly specialized
Color Palette	Reliable, practical	Extensive, designer-led
Paint Quality	Solid, consistent	Premium, high-solids
Durability	Good	Excellent
Price	Competitive	Higher
Sustainability	Low-VOC options	Advanced eco-certified lines
Availability	Regional + online	Nationwide + online
Professional Use	Value-driven	Premium-focused

---

Kelly Moore vs. Benjamin Moore – Tips for Choosing the Right Paint

There are seemingly endless options for paint waiting for you to choose from.

Choosing the paint that you’re going to be happy with on your walls for years to come can be stressful, even for the most experienced painters out there.

Below are a few tips to consider when choosing the best paint (between Kelly Moore and Benjamin Moore) to make sure you are satisfied with the end result:

• Choose colors that complement the existing furniture in your home.
• Figure out what you want the colors in your home to do and how you want them to affect the mood.
• Think about how you want the color to affect your mood–do you want something calming, invigorating, or neutral?
• It is best to do a bit of research and read real customer reviews on the type and color of paint that has caught your eye before making your purchase.

Does the Brand of Paint Really Make a Difference?

Paint isn’t one of those products where the quality or brand can be skimped on; if you don’t choose good paint, you’ll notice it on the walls.

Quality paints will last longer and spread further on the walls, which is what you want.

Thicker coats and better coverage come with more pigments, which are found in quality paint.

This means that, yes, it does make a difference, so you’ll want to do your research on whatever you pick.

For me, Kelly Moore, Benjamin Moore, and Sherwin Williams are the three most popular brands to choose from. And I can’t think of any other brand besides these.

Although all three will have pros and cons, if you choose between them, I am pretty sure you won’t be disappointed.

The Bottom Line

In short, while Benjamin Moore is not part of Kelly-Moore Paints, the best choice ultimately depends on your priorities, your project scale, and the result you want to see on your walls.

If you’re comparing the two, the good news is that you really can’t go wrong—both brands are known for quality, consistency, and professional-grade performance.

Benjamin Moore stands out for its widespread availability, strong brand recognition, and technically refined formulations, making it a practical option for large or time-sensitive projects.

Kelly-Moore, on the other hand, has built a dependable reputation by focusing on value, usability, and hands-on support, which can be especially helpful if you want more guidance throughout the painting process.

At the end of the day, Kelly-Moore excels in practicality and value, while Benjamin Moore leads in precision and premium results. The “better” choice simply comes down to whether you value efficiency or excellence.