Bad Floor Stain Job – Causes and Fixing the Mistakes

Some mistakes that happen while staining wood.

I have stained hardwood floors many times in my lifetime. And it turns out that I am pretty good at it.

But even the best of us make mistakes sometimes. Recently, I stained a floor in our living room and, unfortunately, made a few errors. The result was an ugly, blotchy mess.

You know I am not as good these days as I used to be a few years back!

With my experiences and errors that I still made many times, I have come up with a list of the top mistakes that should be avoided and can be worked on when staining their hardwood floors.

If you have already made any of these mistakes or are about to tackle a staining project and want to avoid them, this detailed article will help you a lot!

Wood Stain Mistakes

Staining the wood is a tricky job. And not all of us are experts in this field.

Not only on hardwood floors, but mistakes can happen while dealing with any kind of wood on your furniture piece or even the cabinets.

But with a bit of practice and know-how, you can easily avoid making the common mistakes while staining your wood surfaces.

The following are some of the habitual mistakes that happen while staining wood:

1- Blotchy Surface

A blotchy surface generally happens when you stain over the wet wood that has not dried completely. 

Moisture and water particles trapped inside the wood fibers can cause blotchiness which can be hard to fix later. 

Not sanding the wood properly before staining is another reason for a blotchy stain job.

If the wood is not sanded evenly and with uniform pressure on the entire surface, the stain will not be absorbed evenly, and you will end up with a blotchy, uneven surface.

Dust, dirt, grime, and debris is also a culprit that can lead to a blotchy surface. 

If you stain the wood without proper cleaning, these particles get trapped inside the coat ruining your efforts and creating a dappled surface.

Lastly, the varying densities of the wood fibers can also lead to a blotchy surface.

If you are working with hardwoods like oak, cherry, and walnut, they will absorb the stain well. 

But the timbers like birch, pine, and poplar are less dense and have spongy areas that don’t absorb the stain evenly. 

Also, these will tend to absorb more stains than other hardwoods. As a result, they will create a blotchy surface.

The Prevention and Fixes: 

The best way to prevent or fix the blotchy stain problem is by:

  • Allowing the wood to dry properly (for at least 48 hours) before applying the stain.
  • Sand the wood properly before staining with uniform pressure throughout the surface. You can use fine-grit sandpaper to ensure an even surface.
  • Cleaning the wood thoroughly with a tack cloth or vacuum cleaner before staining to remove all the dust, dirt, and debris.
  • Testing the stain on a small, inconspicuous area before applying it to the entire surface. This will help you determine the right time to let the stain sit on the wood before wiping it off.
  • Applying a pre-stain wood conditioner before staining will also help to even out the absorption and prevent blotchiness.
  • If the blotchiness has appeared even after trying the above methods, it’s best to sand and reapply the stain to the blotchy surface. 

2- Sticky Stained Surface

After staining the hardwood flooring and waiting for 2-3 days, the surface may still feel sticky. This can be a big problem as it will attract dirt and debris, and you won’t be able to clean it easily.

There can be several reasons for this problem – but the most common is not allowing the wood stain to dry thoroughly before applying the topcoat.

If you apply the topcoat too soon, the stain will not completely dry from the inside, and it will take a long time to dry. As a result, the surface will feel tacky.

Another reason for this problem is using a water-based topcoat over an oil-based stain. This can happen if you are not careful about choosing the right products or if you don’t read the labels properly.

Water-based topcoats are incompatible with oil-based stains and will take a long time to dry. As a result, the surface will feel tacky.

Too much wood stain and thicker coats can also create a sticky surface that is hard to dry. This can be a problem, mainly if you live in an area with high humidity.

The Prevention and Fixes: 

To fix this wood stain problem, you need to:

  • Allow the stain to dry completely before applying the topcoat. This can take up to 48 hours, so be patient.
  • Do not mix water-based stains with oil-based stains. Choose a single product that is best suited for your project.
  • Apply only thin layers of stain and do not coat the wood too much. 2-3 coats will be more than enough for most projects.
  • If the surface is tacky even after 48 hours, sand it lightly and apply another coat of topcoat.

3- Uneven Staining on the Surface

When you accidentally get various light and dark spots all over the stained surface, it usually means that the stain has not been applied evenly. This can be a big problem as it will ruin the overall look of your project.

One of the most common causes of this mess is not stirring the stain properly before applying it. This can cause the pigments to settle at the bottom of the can, and you will end up with an uneven stain.

Another reason for this problem is that the wood stain product you have used was contaminated with other products. 

This can happen if you had used any old stain, had not cleaned the stain container properly before use, or used a dirty brush.

Uneven application and improper sanding and prep work can also lead to this problem.

The Prevention and Fixes: 

To solve this issue, you need to:

  • Mix the stain properly before use to ensure that the pigments are evenly distributed. 
  • Use a new clean stain container and a soft brush for application. Do not use any old products that may be contaminated.
  • Apply 2-3 thin layers of the stain evenly and in a single direction. Do not go over the same area multiple times to fix the mess, as this can lead to uneven absorption.
  • Sand the surface lightly and evenly before staining and remove all the dust particles.

4- Unattractive White Cloudy Finish

An unattractive cloudy finish with unwanted streaks, lap marks, and drips can be a big problem after you have stained your flooring.

This usually happens when you don’t mix the stain pigments properly and/or have used an old brush (or other stain applicators) that are not smooth.

The pigments in the stain usually separate and settle on the surface, mainly if you apply too much stain on the surface with a brush that’s not in good condition. 

These old brushes can leave brush marks and cause the pigments to separate.

The Prevention and Fixes: 

To fix this problem, you need to:

  • Mix the stain pigments properly before use to ensure even distribution.
  • Use a new, clean brush or roller for staining. Do not use any old products that leave streak marks.
  • If the marks or drips still appear, you can either cover the marks with some extra stain or sand down the floor to remove the cloudy finish and start again.

5- Improper Sanding and Curing

Dark spots or marks can sometimes cause if you have not sanded the surface properly before and during the stain application process.

Choosing the right sandpaper grits, applying the correct pressure while sanding, cleaning the surface between the sanding and staining process, etc., are the key things you need to focus on to avoid this problem.

Not paying attention to these can lead to improper drying and curing times. This also means stains get dried too soon, right after the application, without penetrating deep into the wood.

The Prevention and Fixes: 

To fix this problem, you need to:

  • Sand the surface evenly with the right sandpaper grits before and during the staining process. Start with a coarser grit (60-100) and move to a finer one (150-220)
  • Focus on applying even pressure while sanding so you don’t create uneven sanding marks.
  • Use a tack cloth or vacuum cleaner to remove all the dust particles during the sanding and staining process. This will help the stain to adhere correctly to the surface.
  • Follow the recommended drying and curing times for the particular stain you are using to avoid any dark spots or marks.
  • Allow the wood 2-3 days to complete drying and curing. During this time, do not put rugs or mats on the floor as it can cause re-soiling. 

6- Uneven or Wrong Color Shade

This can be very frustrating, especially when you don’t get the desired results.

You have purchased an expensive stain product and are expecting a beautiful and even color shade on your flooring. 

But unfortunately, you end up with an uneven or incorrect color tone that doesn’t match the shade card you have looked at while purchasing.

This can happen for many reasons, such as not mixing the pigments properly, using a non-reliable brand of stain, or the wood being too old. 

Sometimes there can be variations in the grain structure and density of timber along the flooring. 

Some areas might have a higher number of pores that absorb the stain quickly, while others might be denser and take longer to absorb the stain.

The Prevention and Fixes:

To fix this problem, you need to:

  • Use a reliable brand of stain that has good reviews and pigments that provide even coloration.
  • Mix the pigments properly and test the color on a small area before applying it to the entire floor.
  • If the shade is not per your liking, you can either tint it to get the desired tone or replace it with the one you like.
  • Use a brush, roller, or sprayer to apply the stain evenly on the surface.
  • Apply a second coat of stain if needed to get the desired color shade.
  • If the wood is too old, you might need to sand it down to bare wood and redo the staining process.

7- Stain Appears too Dark or too Light

This is one of the most common complaints people make while staining their floors.

The problem can be caused by many reasons, such as the wood type, age, previous finishes on the wood, etc.

Some exotic wood species such as cherry, mahogany, and walnut are naturally very dark. If you are using a light-colored stain on these woods, it will appear too light. 

On the other hand, if you use a dark-colored stain on lighter woods such as maple or oak, it will appear too dark.

Age is also a factor that determines how the stain will look on the flooring. 

If the wood is too old, the stain will not penetrate deep into the pores and appear lighter. In contrast, newer wood absorbs the stain more readily and can appear too dark.

Certain woods also have a very high oil content that will reject oil-based stains and finishes. 

These types of wood do not allow the stain to absorb evenly, resulting in an appearance that is either too dark or too light.

The Prevention and Fixes:

To fix this problem, you need to:

  •  Use a stain that is closer to the desired color shade. For example, use a white or light-colored stain if you want a light color. Use a dark-colored stain like chocolate brown if you want a dark color.
  • If the wood is too old, you might need to sand it down to bare wood before starting the staining process.
  • If the wood has a high oil content, you can try using a water-based or gel stain. These types of wood stains are less likely to be rejected by the wood and will provide more even coloration.
  • If, after application, the stain appears too light, apply another thin coat of stain to get the desired color shade.
  • If, after application, the stain appears too dark, consider applying some paint thinner, alcohol, or bleach to lighten it up. Alternatively, you can sand down the floor to remove a stained layer.

8- Ignoring the Grain and Patterns

Another common mistake while staining the wood floor or furniture is ignoring the grain and fine patterns of the wood. 

Nearly every wood variety will have a unique grain pattern, which needs to be considered while applying the stain.

If the grain is not adequately filled or the stain is not applied evenly, the grain and patterns will be more visible after the stain dries. In some cases, this can result in an ugly appearance that is hard to fix.

The Prevention and Fixes: 

To fix this problem and get flawless staining, you need to:

  • Use a pre-stain conditioner before applying the stain. This will help fill the wood’s pores and make the grain less visible.
  • Apply the stain evenly and with consistent pressure. This will help ensure that the stain is absorbed evenly into the wood and does not highlight the grains more than required.
  • Use a brush, roller, or sprayer to apply the stain evenly on the surface along the grain.
how to fix bad floor stain

9- Allowing the Stain to Dry Before Wiping it off

I have seen that most DIYers make this blunder mistake while staining their wood floors or furniture.

Generally, you must let the stain sit on the surface for a few hours to penetrate deeply.

But if there’s a drip or excess stain, you will need to wipe the excess stain off the surface immediately after applying it.

As soon as you apply the wood stain, it starts drying, and if you don’t wipe it off immediately, it will become difficult to remove. As a result, you will be left with an uneven and ugly finish.

The Prevention and Fixes: 

To fix this problem, you must:

  • If you need to remove the excess stain immediately after applying it, use a clean rag or a brush.
  • Wipe the stain in the direction of the grain to avoid damaging the wood.
  • If the stain has already dried, try to use a paint thinner or mineral spirits to remove it gently. Do not apply the thinner or spirit directly to the wood surface. Instead, soak the rag and then use the soaked rag to wipe off the dried stain.

10- Bad Odor that Stays for Long After the Stain Application

Odor is one of the everyday problems associated with wood stains. Some oil-based stains and finishes can have a strong odor that lingers for days or weeks after the application. 

This can be an issue if you work in a small space with little ventilation. But most of the time, the smell will go away within a week or two if you ventilate the area.

The problem is when there’s still an awkward smell (like rotten eggs or fish) even after ventilating the areas for weeks. 

This usually happens when you have used an old unusable stain that has been lying around in your garage for years.

Or if you have applied the stain in extreme weather conditions like very cold or humid weather.

The Prevention and Fixes: 

To avoid this problem, you must:

  • Avoid applying the stain in cold or humid weather conditions. If you can’t avoid it, try to apply the stain in a well-ventilated area.
  •  Use a high-quality stain that is fresh and has not been lying around for years.
  • If you need to reuse, store the stain properly in a cool and dry place. And use it within a few weeks.
  • If the smell persists for long after the application, try to use a dehumidifier in the room to remove the moisture from the air, which will help remove the odor.

11- Gouge and Machine Marks on the Wood Surface

If you have used the tools such as orbital sanders, planers, or routers carelessly, you will end up with these machine marks. These marks typically show up in corners, edges, and wood that has been carved or milled. 

If the marks have appeared after the staining job (that were not visible before staining), removing them can be extremely tough. Also they can ruin the overall look of your wood project – if you try to fix them now. 

Some stains will tend to highlight those marks, even more, making them visually unappealing and more challenging to fix the fault.

The Prevention and Fixes: 

To avoid this problem from happening, you must:

  • Use fine-grit sandpaper to remove the marks as much as possible before staining.
  • Be extra careful while using the power tools, and don’t apply too much pressure while sanding the wood.
  • Use higher grit sandpaper for the final sanding before staining to avoid any visible marks or scratches.
  • If the marks are still visible after staining, try to use a wood filler to fill them in and then sand the area smooth.

The Bottom Line

So, there you have it. Now you know the causes of a lousy stain job and how to fix them on your flooring.

I hope this article has been helpful and that you are now able to stain your floors without any problems successfully.

Remember that prevention is always better than cure. So, be extra careful while applying the stain and always follow the manufacturer’s instructions to avoid any issues.

Happy staining, and I wish you good luck with your next hardwood floor stain project!

How to Get Rid of Paint Thinner Smell After Home Repaint?
paint thinner smell

One of the greatest feelings in the world is finishing a project. Whether it be remodeling part of your house Read more

How to Get Oil-Based Paint Out of Carpet?
Clean Oil Paint Carpet

Painting your home can be a fun, therapeutic, creative activity. Whether you’re painting peaceful natural landscapes, redoing the walls of Read more

What to Do with Empty Paint Cans – Can They Go in Garbage?
dispose of paint cans

Old & Empty Paint Cans We see continuous development around the globe all the time. Due to this, you can Read more

How to Use TSP Cleaner before Painting Cabinets?
TSP cleaner for cabinets

Repainting your cabinets is a great way to give your kitchen a fresh, newer look. However, there is a deceptive Read more

About | Contact | Disclaimer | Privacy Policy | Terms of Use

error: Content is protected !!